|
Today it is recognised that the cultural differences is often a
barrier when recording by observation and can lead to
misinterpretation. Hence in a European society that gives more value
to a written language than that of an oral language, Tindale’s
version of history can be and is questioned. This is not to deny Tindale’s
contribution to the history of Australia and especially that of
Aboriginal Australia.
Tindale’s
career encompassed a number of research paths across several
decades, one of which started on his first field trip, developing a
project towards the concept of bounded tribal territories. When he
began that project in the 1920s, the popular view was that
Aboriginal groups roamed across the landscape, with no fixed
territories. His
tribal map of Australia (Tribal
Boundaries), first published in 1940 and revised in 1974
together with his encyclopaedia of Aboriginal tribal groups, became
a crucial document in Australian cultural history. It was
radical in its fundamental implication that Australia was not terra
nullius, empty land.
Tindale pioneer work as an Australian archaeologist, was one of
the first to successfully challenge the orthodoxy of the 1920s, that
Aboriginal occupation of Australia had been relatively brief. His
meticulous excavation of a 5,000 year old Aboriginal rock shelter at
Devon Downs on the Murray River in 1929 established not only that
Aboriginal people had lived for several millenia in the Murray
valley, but demonstrated that their strategies for subsistence had
altered in response to environmental change. He showed how stone
tools, animal bones and cultural remains could be used to piece
together a previously untold story about Australia's past. His
foresight in preserving charcoal samples against the predicted
development of C14 dating has received scant recognition.
Nevertheless, critics of Tindale’s construction of an Australian
cultural chronology based on his Devon Downs, Tartanga and even
Noola Rockshelter excavations and his examination of 'Kartan'
implements, acknowledge the precision of his work and the quality of
his data.
Source: South Australian Museum
-
Norman B Tindale |